| Players | Teams | Goal(s) | |
|---|---|---|---|
1. | Alfie May |  | 4 |
- | Paddy Madden | | 4 |
- | Ivan Toney | | 4 |
- | Connor Jennings | | 4 |
5. | Fernando Llorente | | 3 |
- | Lyle Taylor | | 3 |
- | Josh Magennis | | 3 |
- | Tom Denton | | 3 |
- | Kabongo Tshimanga | | 3 |
- | Cauley Woodrow | | 3 |
- | Adi Yussuf | | 3 |
- | Andy Cook | | 3 |
- | Jamille Matt | | 3 |
- | Fejiri Okenabirhie | | 3 |
- | Herbie Kane | | 3 |
- | John Marquis | | 3 |
- | Padraig Amond | | 3 |
18. | Shane Ferguson | | 2 |
- | Andre Green | | 2 |
- | Álvaro Morata | | 2 |
- | Tyrese Campbell | | 2 |
- | Joe Willock | | 2 |
- | Serge Aurier | | 2 |
- | Britt Assombalonga | | 2 |
- | Nathan Redmond | | 2 |
- | Jabo Ibehre | | 2 |
- | Alex Addai | | 2 |
- | Byron Moore | | 2 |
- | Charles Vernam | | 2 |
- | Harry Cornick | | 2 |
- | Adam Rooney | | 2 |
- | Kieffer Moore | | 2 |
- | Joe Dodoo | | 2 |
- | Oliver Palmer | | 2 |
- | Sam Mantom | | 2 |
- | George Miller | | 2 |
- | Matthew Godden | | 2 |
- | Ollie Norburn | | 2 |
- | Elliott List | | 2 |
- | Callum Lang | | 2 |
- | Billy Kee | | 2 |
- | James Henry | | 2 |
- | Craig Robson | | 2 |
- | James Norwood | | 2 |
45. | Harry Kane | | 1 |
- | Chris Wood | | 1 |
- | Troy Deeney | | 1 |
- | Jay Fulton | | 1 |
- | Marko Arnautovic | | 1 |
- | Jordan Ayew | | 1 |